Document Type
Article
Publication Date
Spring 2024
Abstract
A user fee is a fee assessed by the government when it provides a good or service to a private party. Classic examples include the fee to enter Yellowstone National Park and payment to the U.S. Postal Service for a first-class postage stamp. In these transactions, the government provides a specific benefit to an identifiable recipient, who pays the fee. Although the federal government has assessed user fees since this country's founding, broad authorizing legislation in the middle of the 20th century made it possible for agencies to craft user fee programs on their own initiative. Interest in relying on user fees rather than general revenue (taxes) intensified in the final quarter of the century as the federal courts sorted through issues relating to the constitutionality of user fees and concerns mounted about the growing federal debt.
Today, hundreds of user fees are in place across dozens of agencies, and collections exceed more than $500 billion per year. Congress has now supplemented the broad mid-century authorizing legislation with statutes that authorize or require specific agencies to collect user fees. Some enactments are prescriptive (even as to the amount collected), while others specify a formula or objective (such as full cost recovery). Some statutory authorizations are permanent, while others are slated to expire, so continuing to collect fees requires reauthorization. Some agencies are fully funded by user fees, some agencies have discrete programs that are fully funded by user fees, and some agencies receive only modest support from user fees. Some agencies collect more money from fees in a year than they will use that year and maintain the leftover funds in a reserve fund in the event of a shortfall, while others do not. And so on.
This Article examines the design and implementation of user fee programs across the Executive Branch. Design means design both at the congressional level (i.e., the drafting of statutory user fee authority) and at the agency level (i.e., the implementing of statutory user fee authority). This Article discusses design decisions that must be made and the choices available; identifies practical and legal constraints on the choices available; explores the relationship between these choices and core values of administrative law; and explains how program designers might make these choices, as a procedural matter and as a substantive matter. On the basis of this discussion and informed by a series of stakeholder interviews, this Article offers recommendations for agencies and lawmakers relating to user fee design and implementation.
Recommended Citation
Erika Lietzan,
User Fee Programs, 76 Administrative Law Review 375
(2024).
Available at: https://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/facpubs/1307